Choosing a Reloader

---

One Shooter's Experiences and Opinions

 

The purpose of this document is to describe my personal experiences in choosing and using a reloader to load .45 ACP ammunition for Bullseye pistol competition.  Since I have owned (and still own) only two reloaders, I realize there are many others who have experience on a greater variety of reloading equipment.  Still, I believe you will find this essay useful and informative.

 

This document is not intended to describe the reloading process, therefore you will not see a lot about the number one concern in reloading:  SAFETY.  But just as a precaution I will mention it here.  By all means, whatever reloader you choose and use, be aware of how it works and take all safety measures to ensure you are loading safe rounds and that your procedures themselves are safe. 

 

Also, this document is chock-full of my opinions.  If you disagree with any of them, that's fine with me.  My goal is simply to relate my experiences in hopes that it helps some other shooter/reloader.  Please note that in this document I use the word "reloader" to mean "the reloading press" as well as "the person who operates the reloading press", but you can tell which is which based on the context of the sentence.

 

Until about 5 years ago, I had never reloaded any ammunition.  Like most shooters, I had read quite a bit about it and understood the basic process, and of course I had seen ads for TONS of reloaders.  Plus I had heard from many people the various virtues of the many makes and models of reloading presses.  Getting into reloading wasn't that important to me until I got into Bullseye shooting.  When this happened, I quickly realized the only way to go was to start reloading.  Match quality ammo is hard to find and expensive.

 

To get started, I asked several other Bullseye shooters for their recommendations on choosing a reloader.  Not knowing all the details myself, the large amount of info I received was kind of overwhelming.  I mean, gee whiz, do I need a balance beam scale or a digital scale?  What about primers?  What the heck is a primer flip tray?  Are there any "gotchas" for the various reloader makes and models?  And (frequently) why is Bob telling me one thing and Bill is telling me the opposite?

 

Luckily I knew someone who was selling a Dillon Square Deal B for a good price.  I bought it along with quite a few accessories and asked a long-time Bullseye shooter and reloader to show me how to reload.  My instructor helped me set up the machine and showed me step-by-step the process of reloading. 

 

The Square Deal is what I consider a high-quality, entry-level reloader.  Many would disagree with that assessment.  I can see where some people would say that this is a top of the line, complicated, and pretty darned fast progressive reloading press only experienced reloaders should consider buying.  On the other hand, I can also see where some would say that the Square Deal is a poor choice because it is a slow, cumbersome reloader that no serious shooter could deal with for long.

 

How can opinions vary to that degree?  Allow me to explain.

 

Obviously, the process of reloading can be a dangerous thing.  I certainly wear protective glasses while reloading and am very careful in the reloading process.  After all, you DO NOT want a double charge of powder in a round of .45 ACP.  Some people are naturally careful and pay attention to details when they do something that's potentially dangerous.  Like driving a car for example...some people are naturally cautious and rarely get into accidents.  Others are naturally not-so-cautious and get into fender-benders regularly.

 

Because reloading has the potential to be dangerous, and because people have differing natural tendencies, many people recommend that the newbie reloader should only get a single-stage reloading press.  Ok, fine.  That will work.  It will be slow and it will add quite a lot of steps that the progressive reloading press handles automatically.  If you've ever reloaded ammunition (shotgun shells for example), you've probably already formed your own opinion of whether or not reloading is something you simply must do one step at a time, or if you're comfortable enough to let the machine handle some of the steps for you.

 

Getting back to the Square Deal, in my opinion it is an excellent reloader at a price that's very hard to beat.  I'm guessing they're about $250 currently.  Dillon is behind it and will support you any way they can.  It is a progressive reloader, so all you have to do is put the bullet on top of the charged/primed case and put an empty case in the first station.  Then you pull the handle all the way down, push it all the way back up, and voila you have a loaded round come out the end.  The first station resizes the empty (already shot) case and deprimes it.  The second station puts in the new primer at the end of the upstroke (when you push the handle all the way back up).  On the downstroke, the second station drops the powder charge into the case and bells the mouth of the case to make ready for the bullet.  The third station seats the bullet (pushes it down into the case).  The fourth station crimps the case mouth around the bullet.

 

Your process goes like this on the Square Deal (and is similar for most other progressive reloaders).  Put in a new, empty, already shot case into the first station.  Put a bullet on the case in the third station (where there's the primed/charged case).  Pull the handle all the way down and push it all the way back up.  The shell plate turns during this process and spits out the finished round from the fourth station.  Do it again...put in the new case, put on the new bullet, pull down the handle and push it back up.  Another round done.  Over and over.  Case, bullet, pull, push.  Case, bullet, pull, push.

 

So what else could you want?  Anything wrong with the Square Deal?  Well, even though that process is pretty simple and produces great rounds, other machines can be faster.  Also, on the Square Deal you're limited to pistol rounds only.  No reloading for your .30-06 on the Square Deal.  The biggest issue (according to some people) with the Square Deal is that the reloading dies are specifically made for it.  In other words, if you only have .45 ACP dies, but your buddy has a set of "standard" dies to reload .357 Magnums, you can't use them in your Square Deal.  Most reloaders use "standard" size dies.  But the Square Deal uses its own unique size. 

 

In case you don't know, the dies are the little pieces that do the various jobs at each station in the reloading press.  There's a resizing/depriming die in the first station.  This is a piece of steel (usually with a very hard carbide ring inside) which the first case is forced into (by you pulling down on the handle and using a great deal of leverage to make it easy on you) and is squeezed down to normal size.  In the center of this die is a depriming pin.  Basically this is a straight pin like a small nail that goes down through the flash hole in the case and pushes out the spent primer.  Another die is the powder charging/case-mouth belling die (usually just called the "charging die").  This die has a piece in the center which is shaped something like a funnel.  So when the case is forced up into this die, the mouth of the case is "belled" out.  At the same time, a charge of powder is dropped into the case. 

 

Enough explanation of what "dies" are.  Hopefully you get the picture.  If you have a reloader which uses standard dies, you can simply go out and buy dies made by most any manufacturer for most any caliber and they will work in your reloader.  If you plan to reload more than one caliber, this is a pretty good advantage.  On the other hand, if you have the Square Deal, you'll have to buy dies made just for the Square Deal.

 

All that being said, consider what that really means regarding the dies.  Is it REALLY a big deal?  Theoretically, yes it is.  However, when you go buy a set of dies to load .357s on your machine that you previously only loaded .45 ACPs on, you've still got several other things to buy anyway.  Like the shell plate.  Those .357s aren't gonna fit into the shell plate made for the .45s.  Depending on what model of reloader you have, you may need a new case feed attachment, positioning pins, and so on.  So reloading a different caliber isn't as easy as picking up a new set of dies anyway.

 

Also, what's the big deal that you have to buy those Square Deal dies?  Umm...that reloader has been around for YEARS and YEARS and YEARS and it ain't going away.  There will be dies made for it FOREVER.  If you need Square Deal dies, chances are someone already has them, and Dillon sure as heck has them to sell to you. 

 

The reason I went into so much detail on the dies is that this is the factor many people point out about the Square Deal.  "Oh it doesn't use standard dies."  Well that's right.  But all you have to do is order the Square Deal dies instead of the standard dies.  Big deal.

 

To me the biggest POTENTIAL issue is whether or not you plan to load for a rifle.  If you do, remember that the Square Deal doesn't do that.  Then again if you don't plan to reload rifle ammo, obviously this is not an issue.

 

What about other issues you hear about when discussing reloading equipment?  Like, does it break?  Does it jam? 

 

Due to the many moving parts of progressive reloaders, I would imagine that all of them jam or break somewhere along the line.  In my experience with the Square Deal, one little spring broke on it.  I don't even remember what function the spring served, but it finally snapped after so much usage.  To fix it, I just used that same spring and bent the end of it so it would fit back into its hole again.  Hasn't broken since.  Regarding jams, the only thing I had happen more than a few times was that the primers would sometimes get out of whack so that when the primer came up from the bottom (in preparation to be seated into the new case) it would catch on the edge of the shell plate and would sometimes flip upside down or sideways or jam altogether. 

 

To resolve this issue, the first thing I did was read the manual and I found where you could adjust the timing of that little system.  I then proceeded to adjust the wrong *$&#$^ little hex-headed screw off and on for about a year.  Since I was adjusting the wrong ##$@* little screw all that time, it obviously didn't help much.  In the meantime, I took off the shell plate and, using a drill bit MUCH larger than the holes (it was actually a countersink bit), reamed the holes in the bottom of the shell plate so that the edges weren't sharp.  I didn't make the holes bigger, just took the edges off them.  This helped a lot since the primers were off just a hair when they got out of synch.  Of course, later I figured out that I'd been messing with the wrong screw.  When I actually adjusted the right screw, this problem went away. 

 

What about the quality of the reloads?  Awesome.  It turned out great rounds.  Very consistent.  Very rarely did I have a round that for one reason or another was "fat" or had any other flaws. 

 

Now on to the next reloader - the Dillon XL650.  I know I'm throwing in a lot of personal opinions into this document anyway, but here's the most blatant one -- this is the reloader everyone needs.  Ok fine, maybe not "needs".  Maybe not "everyone".  But if you gave all these bullseye shooters loading on Lee's or Lyman's or RCBS (or Dillon models lower than the 650) a brand spanking new Dillon XL650, they'd slap themselves for not buying one earlier.  (Yes...I know...I've never had a Lee reloader, so how in the world can I say that?  Because this is my article…HA!)

 

Yeah, yeah.  I know.  This is the same type of "information" people always bestow on those trying to choose a reloader to purchase.  Everyone has the best reloader.  Everyone thinks theirs is the greatest.  I'll try to be more objective.

 

The thing about the 650 is that it has all the good features of the Square Deal, plus a whole lot more.  First of all, while the Square Deal is a high-quality machine, the XL650 is a heavy-duty extra-high-quality machine.  That sucker is solid.  In the grand scheme of things that's not so big of a deal.  Heck, it'd be very hard to ever wear out the Square Deal or practically any other reloader.

 

The 650 can also be set up to feed the new cases for you.  In other words, remember on the Square Deal where the process was "put in a new case, put on a new bullet, pull the handle down, push the handle up"?  Well on the 650, the case feeder (sold separately) does the first step for you.  So your right hand never even leaves the handle.  It goes like this:  "new bullet, pull, push".  That's it.  MUCH faster.  Here we go on that whole speed topic.  By the way, this is where many people bring up the "yeah, it's fast, but you have to be extra extra careful with one of those newfangled progressive reloaders" argument.  To which I would reply "you have to be extra extra careful with ANY reloader no matter how slow it is".  The thing about progressive reloaders isn't that you have to rush to produce ammunition at a relatively fast pace.  Just the opposite.  You can go as slowly in your process as you want, and still produce ammo pretty quickly.

 

So how big of a deal is speed?  That depends on how important it is to you as an individual.  Without actually timing it, I'd say the 650 is a little more than twice as fast as the Square Deal.  By never having to take your hand off the handle, you get an easy rhythm going.  Just put the bullet on and work the handle.  When I first heard about the speed, I thought it was no big deal.  The Square Deal was plenty fast.  At the time I was shooting at least one 2700 a weekend and sometimes two.  And I was reloading for another shooter at the same time!  Now you're probably thinking, "Well yeah, if you're loading that much ammo you want something fast."  Yep, but now that I'm shooting maybe one match a month, it's still important to have that speed.  Since I'm not full-throttle into shooting right now, I'm shooting less rounds than in the past.  Which means I REALLY don't want to spend time reloading!  I can crank out enough ammo for a match for 2 people in one evening with absolutely no problem (and still have time to eat dinner and work around the house).

 

Overall, the operation of the Square Deal is what I would consider "typical" for a progressive reloader.  You put in the case, then the bullet, and work the handle.  Other reloaders work basically the same way.  The only difference is that a reloader with an automatic case feeder (like you can get with the 650 and several other makes and models) eliminates the step where you put in the new case. 

 

Also note that the features listed for many reloaders say "self-indexing".  This just means that when you work the handle, the shell plate turns automatically, moving the cases from one station to the next.  On some reloaders, you have to turn the shell plate yourself.  Take the Dillon 550 for example.  I don't know all the details and features of this model, but I do know that you have to turn the shell plate manually.  So, in addition to the usual steps, after you work the handle, you take your finger and turn the shell plate one notch to move the cases to the next station.

 

Personally, I don't like the idea of this at all.  I'm sure there are safety measures in place so that reloaders which do not self-index prevent you from cranking the handle again without moving the shell plate.  But if you don't move the shell plate and somehow crank the handle again, you could get a double charge of powder in a case.  Like I said, there may be a million different safety measures to prevent this but it still makes me wary.  On a self-indexing reloader, the cases get moved to the next station by you operating the handle.  This means that right after you drop the powder in a case, it gets moved to the next station.  Therefore there is very little chance of you dropping another charge of powder into it.  But hey, who's to say that the shell plate won't simply stick and not get indexed to the next station?  Anything can happen.  But I think as you reload you'd notice something very strange if that happened.  For one thing, when you went to put a bullet in the next case it would already be there, sending you a red flag right away.  Again...as a disclaimer...I do not know the in's and out's of the reloaders where you have to turn the shell plate by hand.  But I would imagine it has to be slightly slower since there's an extra step involved. 

 

The 650 can reload practically any caliber...pistol or rifle.  And it does use standard sized dies so you can go out and get dies made by Lee or RCBS or whomever and put them in your 650 if you so desire.  While we're back on the subject of dies, I'll share my opinions on some things you may hear.  Lots of .45 ACP shooters don't like Dillon dies because they tend to size the .45 case smaller than many other manufacturers' dies.  You'll hear people talk about rounds from a Dillon machine being shaped like a Coke bottle.  They'll talk about how this unnecessarily "works" the brass.  This will lead to talk about how it will wear out your brass more quickly than other brands of dies.  While these things may be true, again I ask "what does this REALLY mean?"

 

In my experience, I avoided the Dillon dies for quite a long time.  First I had some very old dies (can't remember the manufacturer right now) which sized the cases larger than most dies.  In other words, in the first station where the case is resized, it squeezed it down only slightly.  This produced rounds which were quite straight (not like a Coke bottle).  I was very happy with this and several people commented on how nice my reloads looked.  Well, whoopty-doo.  I don't care if my rounds are prettier than anything Federal or Winchester has ever produced.  Furthermore, I think it would be extremely hard to measure whether or not the brass actually wears out faster if you size them with Dillon dies versus any other die.  For crying out loud, brass eventually splits and you toss it out.  Before you know it, you'll have 5 gallon buckets of brass sitting all around the house.  You'll go out to the garage one day and say "Where in the hell did all this brass come from?"  So why be concerned about wearing it out?  Like I said, I don't even know if it wears out faster if you size it smaller or not!

 

Back to my tale of dies.  After a while I noticed that the dies I had were scarring the brass when it resized the case.  I figured they needed cleaning so I took them out and cleaned them.  Taking them out means you unscrew them and when you put them back, you have to adjust them all back to the point where they work.  Meaning you spend anywhere from 15 minutes to an hour screwing the dies in an out until they're in what you think is the right place.  But you really don't know if they're back in the right spot or not.  This isn't all that big of a deal, but it does make you wonder whether or not you changed something that affects the accuracy or reliability of your ammo.  I've never noticed a problem, but then again, I used to spend quite a bit of time on triple checking everything whenever I put my dies back in. 

 

Cleaning those old dies helped for a while, but the scarring eventually got worse again.  So I bought a set of Lee dies because everyone talked so highly of them.  They worked fine.  Nothing special.  The sizing die sized the case down a little smaller than the old set of dies, so the Coke bottle effect was there, but not much.

 

About that time, I became concerned with seating the bullet perfectly straight at the seating station.  Plus I was considering loading a different shape of bullet (long-nosed vs short-nosed).  There's an RCBS (I think) seating die called a "Competition Die" which pushes the bullet down into the case by contacting the shoulder of the bullet only.  Most dies push down on the end of the bullet.  There's a little cup in the seating die so that the end of the bullet naturally gets aligned straight up and down.  But, in theory, if the die pushes on the shoulder of the bullet instead, it should be "better".  Plus this "Competition Die" allows you to load either the long-nosed or short-nosed bullet since it doesn't push on the nose, it pushes on the shoulder.  With a conventional seating die, you'd have to adjust the die when you went back and forth from short- to long-nosed bullets (picture the long-nosed bullet getting pushed too far down into the case if you had the die set for a short-nosed bullet).  For some reason, I had lots of trouble with the Competition Die and could never get it to seat bullets properly.  Beats me why, but I tried and tried.  So I went back to the Lee seating die.

 

There I was with a set of Lee dies and I think I had some other brand in there somewhere, and mix-and-match for a while as well.  Anyway this was fine.  No problems really.  Except of course if I wanted to clean them there was the usual 30 minutes to an hour of readjusting dies.

 

Finally for some reason I decided to bite the bullet and go ahead and order a set of Dillon dies.  A friend of mine recommended them because of how easy they are to clean.  I always avoided them because of the whole Coke bottle thing and because they are more expensive than most other dies.

 

Holy cow!  No wonder they're more expensive.  I love those dies.  First of all, they do produce a round that's kinda Coke bottle shaped.  But not bad...and like I said before...who cares?  They are designed so that once you get them set up, you can simply pull a pin on each die and they drop out so you can clean them.  Then you just pop 'em back in and you're back in business.  Once again, how big of a deal is this?  Not a huge deal.  You don't have to clean your dies very often.  Like once a year is probably average.  Some people maybe 2 or 3 times a year, others maybe once every 2 or 3 years.  Depends.  The point is these dies work, they work well, and they're easy to clean if you so desire.

 

There are other selling points for the 650, like the fact that the toolhead (where the dies are screwed in) is easily removable so you can pull out toolhead number 1 (say it's set up to load your .45 target loads) and slide in toolhead number 2 to load your .357 Magnums.  At least that's how Dillon kinda portrays it.  After you do that though, you still have to change out the shell plate and case feed assembly and stuff.  It wouldn't take all that long (maybe 15 minutes or so), but it ain't as easy as sliding in and out different toolheads.  The great thing about the exchangeable toolheads is that you keep all your dies and powder charge settings intact.  No dorking around with all that stuff if you want to change calibers.  Just replace the toolhead and other necessary parts, check everything out (including the powder charge, bullet seating, and crimping) and away you go.

 

Another feature is that there's an extra station on the 650 where you can put a die that does a powder check.  Basically, it protrudes down into the case and based on how far down it goes before it gets to the gunpowder it mashes a little device that sounds an alarm if the amount of powder is off significantly.  It does NOT check the ACCURACY of the amount of powder in the case.  But it will sound the alarm if you have a double-charge or no powder in the case.  In all my reloading so far I have never double-charged a case, but this alarm has sounded several times when there was a big old piece of dirt still in the case.  So the case was pretty full of stuff (dirt and gun powder) and the little beeper thingy warned me of this.  I imagine those rounds would have been light since it would have been hard for the powder to get ignited properly with all that dirt in the way.

 

 

WHAT I'VE HEARD

 

So far I've told you about stuff I know about.  Now for the stuff I've only heard about or have seen, but don't claim to be an expert on.

 

Many shooters use the Lee reloader.  I'm sure it is a quality machine and comes with all sorts of bells and whistles just like the Dillons.  However, the people I've seen who have dud rounds (no powder in the case, just a primer) all use Lee reloaders.  I know of 3 people who have loaded dud rounds more than once and they all used Lee reloaders.  Maybe it's the person, maybe it's the machine.  I have heard you have to be careful in your process to make sure the powder charge gets dropped into the case when using the Lee reloader.  Here again, I plead ignorance.  This is only something I have heard and can't verify personally.

 

Other people swear by the Star reloader.  I don't think these are made any more.  I believe this machine is probably the workhorse of all reloaders.  People have loaded and loaded and loaded on these and they very, very rarely have anything break.  That being said, I believe you have to manually turn the shell plate on these but I'm not sure.  Seems like there's some attachment you can get that makes it self-index.  The only thing I don't care for about these is the fact that they are currently being manufactured.  This would cause me to worry about getting spare parts if you ever needed them.  Plus I don't know, but I doubt they offer all the bells and whistles of some other loaders.  Maybe you can get an automatic case feeder for them, but I don't know if you can or not.  And although these are probably the toughest reloaders, what does that mean to you?  I don't see me ever being able to wear out my Dillons.  Like I said before, I imagine all reloaders are pretty tough machines.  I've not had any parts break on either reloader (except that spring I already mentioned).  Furthermore when something breaks, you can call the manufacturer and many of them simply ship you the part you need free of charge.  Dillon is famous for this and I believe a few other companies are about the same way.

 

A final testimony for the 650 is that two of the best shooters I know (well, those who aren't in the Marines and don't have to reload) reload on Dillon XL650s.  I load on the 650 also and highly recommend it.  If you have the money, get it with the automatic case feeder and Dillon dies.  Also, mount the loader on a nice sturdy bench, because if you have a wobbly bench, it can sometimes adversely effect the operation of the automatic case feeder.  And having a sturdy bench is a good idea anyway since you'll be applying quite a bit of force to the handle of the reloader and don't want a bench wobbling all over the place. 

 

 

OTHER EQUIPMENT

 

So much for the reloaders, now for a brief word on other required equipment.  My list below may not be perfect so you may want to jot it down and make changes to it as you talk to other shooters/reloaders.  I'll list the item and brief opinion.

 

Scales - I use balance beam instead of digital - you need scales for SURE so you can check your powder charge - mine is a Dillon and works just fine.

 

Brass tumbler - This is the vibrating thing you pour your brass into, along with ground walnut hulls or whatever, and turn it on for a couple of hours to clean your brass.  By the way, those walnut hulls or ground corn cob stuff is referred to as "polishing media" or just "media".  I have the Dillon CV-500 vibratory case cleaner.  (There's a big one and a small one, mine is the small one.)  I like mine, but wish I had the bigger one (model CV-2001) only because I like to clean a whole bunch of brass at once and get it in the "clean bucket". 

 

Brass/media separator - This may not be the right name, but it's basically the thing you pour the brass and walnut hulls into after it's clean.  Pour it all in, roll this thing over and over and the walnut hulls fall out, leaving your brass.  I cheaped out and bought an inexpensive one.  It works, but I would try a different model now.  If I couldn't find any to try (like at a friend's house or whatever), I'd take a chance and get one from Dillon (being careful to get the big one if I got the big tumbler).  A word here on the "media" you use to clean the brass.  I first used ground walnut hulls.  Works just fine but is fairly dusty.  Then I got some corn cob media.  This worked great too and was a little less dusty than the walnut, plus it made the brass shiny (which doesn't really matter but looked nice).  I haven't been able to find good media that isn't sold as "brass cleaning media".  What I mean is, lots of people go to the pet store and get ground corn cob stuff you put in the bottom of a guinea pig cage.  This works, but all of it I've used isn't ground nearly as fine as the stuff truly meant for brass cleaning.  It doesn't quite clean as well or last as long as the good stuff either.  My advice is to buy some stuff from a reloading supply place that's made for cleaning brass.  Give it a try and then you can go out and experiment with other types of media.  Maybe you'll find a great solution and let all us other Bullseye shooters know.  Actually, ask around and someone will probably have done the research for you.

 

Primer flip tray - you need one so you can fill up your primer tubes.  I got a cheap RCBS one and it works great.  I imagine they all do. 

 

By the way, one of these days you'll run across an ad for the Dillon automatic primer tube filler.  This thing is expensive for what it does.  I mean you can buy a primer flip tray for just a few dollars.  Seems like the Dillon automatic primer filler costs over $200.  As a present to myself a couple of years ago, I bought one anyway.  That thing is great!  I use Winchester primers and have heard there's a problem with Federal ones in this little machine.  That's what I've ­heard, not witnessed.  Anyway, the process is...you dump a pack of 100 primers into the machine and hit the "go" button.  Then, for the first couple of hundred times you do this, you have to watch those little primers race each other to get into the tube.  Well, you don't have to, but it's hard to resist!  It's amazing and cool to watch.  I've had 1 jam on this machine in many, many, many hundreds of iterations.  Took me about 2 minutes to clear it. 

 

One common misconception about this machine is that it loads primer tubes.  I pictured myself taking all my primer pick-up tubes and filling them up using the automatic primer filler.  It actually comes with a tube of its own and it's not a regular old primer pick-up tube.  Basically the machine fills up this tube and you take that tube and load up your reloader with it.  So you really don't fill up your old primer tubes all at once. 

 

My process goes like this so that I really never wait the 30 seconds it takes for the machine to fill up the tube.  Once my reloader has run out of primers, I fill it back up from the tube on the automatic primer filler, then before I start reloading again, I dump a pack of primers into my nifty little machine and press the button.  If I can refrain from watching the primers race into the tube, I can then start loading again.  The primer filler automatically stops after 1 minute and it's usually put all the primers into the tube within about 20 to 30 seconds.

 

I'm not saying you should buy the automatic primer filler, but if you ever have the "extra" money (yeah right) and just wonder how well it works, rest assured that it works great.  And even though $200+ is a LOT of money to spend on something it only takes you a couple of minutes to do by hand, I believe it is worth it.  I for one do not plan to manually load primer tubes ever again.

 

Primers - get Winchester or Federal - they're called Large Pistol Primers (sometimes they say for Large or Magnum pistol calibers, just make sure they're for Large Pistol, not Magnum only)

 

Gun Powder - I'm not going to get into this one, but I use Bullseye powder made by Alliant.  I use it because a billion other bullseye shooters before me have used it, it works, everyone knows good loads for it, and it's not too expensive.  Others will say it's dirty.  Beats me.  I guess it might be dirty compared to some others.

 

Calipers - Is that the right word?  I'm talking about dial calipers so you can measure your rounds.  Check to see how long the rounds are, how much crimp you put on them, etc.  These are nice to have, but you don't use them very often and might get away without having them for a while.  If you get calipers, buy good ones made of steel (not plastic).

 

Bullets - Here again there will be a million opinions on this.  I use Valiant bullets.  They're good and they're cheap.  I may switch to LaserCast or Star bullets though.  Depends on whether or not I ever get around to testing them.

 

I'm sure I'm leaving off some equipment you need, just can't think of it.

 

SUMMARY

 

In summary, I'm not a Dillon salesman and I'm sure other brands of reloaders work great as well.  What I'm saying is that with the equipment I recommend in this document, you can reload safely and efficiently without going through some of the problems I did. 

 

Remember - safety and consistency. You are not using the progressive reloader to set speed records.  You are using it to create the most consistent loads you can in the most efficient amount of time.